In one of his final acts before leaving office next week, Rep. Bob Goodlatte blocked a bill intended to improve the federal government’s response to violence against Native American women.
A spat between the Republican congressman, whose district is home to the largest Indian tribe in Virginia, and the bill’s sponsor, outgoing Sen. Heidi Heitkamp (D.-N.D.), has played out publicly over the past week.
In a tweet, Heitkamp, who lost her bid for reelection, urged people to ask their representatives to pressure Goodlatte to clear the way for the bill, which the Senate passed unanimously this month.
It stalled in the House because Goodlatte, chairman of the Judiciary Committee, declined to bring it up for a vote. House Republican leaders could directly bring Heitkamp’s measure to the floor, bypassing Goodlatte, but so far have declined to do so.
Goodlatte told the Roanoke Times that he supports the intent of the bill but objects to a provision that would give preference to certain law enforcement agencies in applying for grants from the Justice Department. Goodlatte, who did not seek reelection this year after 13 terms in office, said Heitkamp’s attempt to pressure him was “just ridiculous.”
The bill’s apparent demise comes days after another debacle for the Republican-led Congress on the issue of protecting abuse victims. Last Friday, a deadlock over President Trump’s border wall plunged the federal government into a partial shutdown, leading to the expiration of the Violence Against Women Act, the 1994 law that provides funding for programs that help victims of sexual assault, domestic abuse and stalking.
With the House adjourned until further notice, it appears unlikely that Heitkamp’s measure, known as Savanna’s Act, will receive a vote before the new session of Congress begins Jan. 3.
Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) has said she will reintroduce it then.
“It’s disappointing that one Republican member of Congress blocked Savanna’s Act from passing this year,” Heitkamp said in a statement. “But fortunately, Rep. Goodlatte won’t be around to block it in the new Congress.”
The offices of House Speaker Paul D. Ryan (R-Wis.) and Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) did not immediately respond to requests for comment Thursday.
Heitkamp’s bill is named after Savanna LaFontaine-Greywind, a 22-year-old pregnant woman killed by a woman who wanted to abduct her baby.
It would direct the Justice Department to boost data-collection efforts on crimes against Native Americans; expand tribal access to federal crime information databases; and establish guidelines for law enforcement in responding to cases of missing or killed Native Americans.
In a statement this month, Heitkamp said she aimed to “spark a nationwide call to action against the growing crisis of missing and murdered indigenous women and girls,” calling the Senate’s passage of the bill “a major step in raising awareness about this growing epidemic.”
Goodlatte told the Roanoke Times that he objects to a provision in the bill that would give preference for grants to law enforcement agencies that comply with the reporting requirements in Savanna’s Act, as opposed to other agencies that have no link to tribal communities and therefore cannot fulfill those requirements.
“The problem is that the way that law was written, it took existing funds available to law enforcement organizations and used it as a reward for people who complied with provisions of the reporting requirements of Savanna’s Act,” Goodlatte told the newspaper.
Goodlatte, who will be succeeded by Rep.-elect Ben Cline (R), has frequently raised the ire of Democrats, including when he tried to strip the House ethics office of its independence and ability to investigate anonymous claims in 2017.
Years ago, he questioned efforts to give federal recognition to six Virginia Indian tribes. But he didn’t fight the measure when it made it through Congress this year and was signed by Trump.
The change in status affected the 4,400 members of the Chickahominy, the Eastern Chickahominy, the Upper Mattaponi, the Rappahannock, the Monacan and the Nansemond tribes. The Monacan tribe is located in Goodlatte’s district, which stretches from the Shenandoah Valley to the Roanoke Valley and east to Lynchburg.
Karenne Wood, an anthropologist and member of the Monacan tribe, said Goodlatte’s decision to block Heitkamp’s bill suggests that he believes “these women don’t matter.”
Chickahominy Indian Chief Stephen Adkins echoed her concerns. “I am disappointed at his position and I hope he takes another look at his last opportunity to do the right thing for America’s indigenous peoples,” he said.
Source
A spat between the Republican congressman, whose district is home to the largest Indian tribe in Virginia, and the bill’s sponsor, outgoing Sen. Heidi Heitkamp (D.-N.D.), has played out publicly over the past week.
In a tweet, Heitkamp, who lost her bid for reelection, urged people to ask their representatives to pressure Goodlatte to clear the way for the bill, which the Senate passed unanimously this month.
It stalled in the House because Goodlatte, chairman of the Judiciary Committee, declined to bring it up for a vote. House Republican leaders could directly bring Heitkamp’s measure to the floor, bypassing Goodlatte, but so far have declined to do so.
Goodlatte told the Roanoke Times that he supports the intent of the bill but objects to a provision that would give preference to certain law enforcement agencies in applying for grants from the Justice Department. Goodlatte, who did not seek reelection this year after 13 terms in office, said Heitkamp’s attempt to pressure him was “just ridiculous.”
The bill’s apparent demise comes days after another debacle for the Republican-led Congress on the issue of protecting abuse victims. Last Friday, a deadlock over President Trump’s border wall plunged the federal government into a partial shutdown, leading to the expiration of the Violence Against Women Act, the 1994 law that provides funding for programs that help victims of sexual assault, domestic abuse and stalking.
With the House adjourned until further notice, it appears unlikely that Heitkamp’s measure, known as Savanna’s Act, will receive a vote before the new session of Congress begins Jan. 3.
Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) has said she will reintroduce it then.
“It’s disappointing that one Republican member of Congress blocked Savanna’s Act from passing this year,” Heitkamp said in a statement. “But fortunately, Rep. Goodlatte won’t be around to block it in the new Congress.”
The offices of House Speaker Paul D. Ryan (R-Wis.) and Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) did not immediately respond to requests for comment Thursday.
Heitkamp’s bill is named after Savanna LaFontaine-Greywind, a 22-year-old pregnant woman killed by a woman who wanted to abduct her baby.
It would direct the Justice Department to boost data-collection efforts on crimes against Native Americans; expand tribal access to federal crime information databases; and establish guidelines for law enforcement in responding to cases of missing or killed Native Americans.
In a statement this month, Heitkamp said she aimed to “spark a nationwide call to action against the growing crisis of missing and murdered indigenous women and girls,” calling the Senate’s passage of the bill “a major step in raising awareness about this growing epidemic.”
Goodlatte told the Roanoke Times that he objects to a provision in the bill that would give preference for grants to law enforcement agencies that comply with the reporting requirements in Savanna’s Act, as opposed to other agencies that have no link to tribal communities and therefore cannot fulfill those requirements.
“The problem is that the way that law was written, it took existing funds available to law enforcement organizations and used it as a reward for people who complied with provisions of the reporting requirements of Savanna’s Act,” Goodlatte told the newspaper.
Goodlatte, who will be succeeded by Rep.-elect Ben Cline (R), has frequently raised the ire of Democrats, including when he tried to strip the House ethics office of its independence and ability to investigate anonymous claims in 2017.
Years ago, he questioned efforts to give federal recognition to six Virginia Indian tribes. But he didn’t fight the measure when it made it through Congress this year and was signed by Trump.
The change in status affected the 4,400 members of the Chickahominy, the Eastern Chickahominy, the Upper Mattaponi, the Rappahannock, the Monacan and the Nansemond tribes. The Monacan tribe is located in Goodlatte’s district, which stretches from the Shenandoah Valley to the Roanoke Valley and east to Lynchburg.
Karenne Wood, an anthropologist and member of the Monacan tribe, said Goodlatte’s decision to block Heitkamp’s bill suggests that he believes “these women don’t matter.”
Chickahominy Indian Chief Stephen Adkins echoed her concerns. “I am disappointed at his position and I hope he takes another look at his last opportunity to do the right thing for America’s indigenous peoples,” he said.
Source
Ask your member of Congress to tell @RepGoodlatte to stop blocking #SavannasAct & to stand up for Native women who are murdered at 10x the nat'l avg. We must stop these horrible crimes & we are so close to passing my bill in Congress. More from @NBCNews: https://t.co/BkcErauhUm— Sen. Heidi Heitkamp (@SenatorHeitkamp) December 19, 2018
WTH?
Protecting the perps?
The crimes being committed against Native-American women, are usually hidden to the point society is not aware....2018 movie WIND RIVER, tells one of those stories.
hidden by who? The perpetrators or the victims and how is this societies fault? Do we need to legislate for a particular race or color or creed? I think that would violate our constitution. It is against the law to abuse anyone. Man, woman or child. Enforce the law. stop with the politics.
to Just me and my minds eye It would be great if things worked that way. The truth is that it hasn't worked for all of society. Blacks suffer from murder by cop or slave labor in a privatized prison here in the US. It is obvious to me that this years long of murder of native american women must be something similar to the KKK since it is over many areas and not investigated thoroughly or not at all. Someone must know something about it. A young girl did her college thesis on it and was murdered by her neighbors. Take from that whatever you will. Goodlatte was involved in the Abramoff scandal and there was a native American link in that which could mean something or nothing, It is something that should be addressed.
how long has this been going on? people want protection, and this gentlemen isn't paying it any attention? What's it gonna take-- for him- to do so?
These days all GOP Congress members have that Kavanaugh hate-filled scowl on their face. They think they can't be held accountable. They assume that they are above the law because their fake president thinks that he is above the law. 'Monkey see, monkey do'.
How can a republican in the house block a bill when the democrats control the House?
IF YOU CAN NOT STAND UP FOR THE NATIVE PEOPLE OF THIS LAND DO NOT STAND UP FOR THE AMERICAN INVADERS THAT STOLE THIS LAND FROM THE NATIVES. STAND UP FOR ALL OR NONE.
This is not America of my dreams...đź‘Ž
Well, let's see. Is there anything ELSE we can do to try to destroy the Native Americans?
whomever is blocking this bill should be ashamed of themselves
We have robbed them of every piece of dignity they have, why not go a little step further and rob them of everything
Mistreatment of Native Americans has been occurring since white men came to this country. Women are always the most vulnerable citizens of our society. I hope another Congressman and Senator will take up this bill and get it passed.
The reality of America has been about abuse - if one reads the Essay by James Baldwin, Nothing Personal he lays it out plain and clear. Still there is the resilient SPIRIT and it's become obvious our government, our churches are involved with a sinister agenda that protects the circle of pedophiles, human trafficking and the suffering of the vulnerable and most innocent. For more information to help support Indigenous women/ youth/ children to address this sickness plaguing society and return to healthy balance - our co-relationship with the world, within our families and communities. Let the healing begin with us. #Icantbequiet https://www.nativemovement.org/
Before the "dem evil white man" comments show up (Charlene) learn history. Native Americans brutally fought each other before Europeans arrived and even had African slaves once that era began. That being said. More should be done today to protect Native American women. No reason not to pass this important bill.